I was flabbergasted and astounded. What an epic idea! Why can't I come up with ideas like that?
Anyways, as those of you who watch Iron Chef know, the cooking speed and video editting make it impossible to really know how they're cooking anything. Regardless, I decided that I would try my hand at making my own eggnog french toast. I checked my regular recipe sources online, but I was singularly displeased with what I was able to find. French toast itself is not that challenging to make, so I thought I would try my hand at working out the eggnog version on my own.
The trick to a good french toast, at least in my opinion, is getting the ratio of egg and liquid correct. Usually when I make french toast (one serving), I'll use two eggs and just a splash of milk. Obviously this wasn't going to work for eggnog french toast, since just a splash of eggnog wouldn't be enough to get that rich egg flavor. I also used nutmeg and cinnamon to flavor the batter and amp up that Christmas-y spice aroma.
My mom also had about half a cup of milk that she wanted to use up, so she talked me into adding it to the batter. This was a mistake. It really thinned out my batter, and the extra liquid (considering that you already have to add eggnog), which creates some issues for the texture of the finished product. Don't add any extra milk.
This is what my finished batter looked like (before I mixed in the spices):
In the end, based on how things turned out, this is the recipe I would recommend:
- 3 eggs
- 1/3 to 1/2 c. eggnog (this will be based on how thick your batter is and how much of an eggnog flavor you want, just be sure not to add so much that the batter is too watery)
- 1 tsp nutmeg
- 1 tsp cinnamon
- 6 slices texas toast (you can use regular bread if you want, but you'll get better results with thicker slices)
Start by beating the eggs together until frothy. Some recipes I've seen for french toast call for lightly beating the eggs, but the more you beat them, the more air you're pushing into the mixture, which results (in my opinion) in fluffier french toast. Add the eggnog, nutmeg, and cinnamon; beat together thoroughly.
Heat a medium sized skillet on medium heat. Try not to use a skillet that's too much larger that the heating element, since it's better to get even heat distribution. Add some cooking oil or margarine to the pan; if you're using a non-stick skillet you can use a little less oil.
When your skillet is nice and toasty, dip your bread one slice at a time into the batter. Personally, I like to dip my bread relatively quickly, not allowing too much time for the batter to really soak into the bread (I find that makes the inside of the toast perpetually soggy). Do make sure that the bread is completely and evenly coated, and that you allow the excess batter to drip off before dropping the toast into the pan. I like to use chopsticks for this step, but tongs or a set of spatulas would work just as well. You'll find that if you oversoak the bread, it'll start to come apart.
Fry your toast two slices at a time. If it's browning too quickly, lower the heat. Cook for at least two minutes per side; don't forget that even though you've browned the outside, you also need to cook through any batter that's soaked into the center of the bread as well. 5-8 minutes total should be more than enough, based on how hot your stove is, and how much batter you've used on your bread. When you're done, your toast should be golden brown on both sides.
For a special treat, melt a bit of butter in the pan instead of oil and sprinkle in some brown sugar. This will create a sweet, caramalized crust on your toast (great on regular cinnamon french toast).
The result to my experiment was pretty tasty. My results were a little compromised because of the added milk, and the skillet I used was too big.
The addition of nutmeg and cinnamon really brought out the subtle eggnog flavors, probably making the eggnog aroma stronger than it actually was due to the associations between nutmeg and eggnog I've had since childhood. It was ridiculously rich for breakfast, but hey, what's Christmas for, if not for indulgence and adding a couple inches to the waistline?
If anyone decides to try this and has any suggestions to improve this experimental recipe, let me know! I won't be trying this again until next year. On to the Christmas cookies!
Merry Christmas (or, to be PC, happy holidays) :)

